Exam Feedback Tool


Has education, education, education, been bullied by the call for evidence, evidence, evidence. Possibly. However, I am keen to be a part of an evidence based profession, so here is my two-penth. Take the relatively simple, but brilliantly so, Exam Feedback Tool designed by Peter Atherton, an interest in Question Level Analysis, a fantastic Scientist and talented coding mathematician, you are bound to get an evidence based approach. In case you are pondering that summary... That is exactly what you got.

Data is not information, information is not knowledge, knowledge is not understanding, understanding is not wisdom. - Clifford Stoll

In September 2014 I forwarded a copy of the EFT tool to Paul Kearley, Curriculum Leader for Science. We spent sixth months refining it's use. Results were very positive, particularly with the A Level students. Pupils looked forward to receiving the coloured feedback summary page, all part of the EFT (although these were printed one at a time). They were even asking for additional exam questions on the targeted topics. Yes, asking for additional exam questions. I think it was at this point we realised we were onto something.

The EFT was less successful with students/pupils not able to select their own targets (a training issue?) with most opting for vague phrases such as "work harder," '"complete more homework" and "listen in class." We employed training with some success. Come April 2015, Paul and I were confident enough to share our progress with various curriculum areas and the enthusiasm for the EFT spread quickly at the Academy. Sharing resulted in a colleague from the maths department adding two critical enhancements. The NEW and IMPROVED EFT can now;

1. Auto select target areas - algorithmically.

2. Print a full class set of summary sheets (macro)

Exam Feedback Tool Phase 2

Finally, this term, I introduced my Year 8, set 5 Maths class to the EFT. I was more than a little surprised by their response. I have written about that experience, so please do not see the EFT as an "exam only" Year 10-13 tool.

Yesterday Paul and I presented at #TLT15. Our colleagues attending contributed a number of valuable points, here are our collective solutions.

Completing the EFT for one group has a cost. If leaders take responsibility for the EFT, completing the EFT for multiple class or a year group, requires even more time, however enables the group analysis features that enables very powerful teaching-leadership enquiry. Still we have the issues of time.

The time invested in completing the QLA, does not have to rest with the teacher. Pupils can add their own scores to an open spreadsheet, or it potentially provides as excellent task for pupils in detention. Always remembering that working with the EFT reduces the need for extensive feedback on the exam paper itself.

AI captured the attendees attention.

Lastly, I am looking forward to meeting with colleagues from the session and hearing about their successes/reflections on how we could evolve the EFT even further.


Author Profile

Kristian Still

Kristian Still

Proud father & husband. VP. Leadership, PD, assessment, lesson capture, data for TL.

10 stories


Hannah Wilson Hannah Wilson @misswilsey 2 years ago
Welcome to staffrm Kristian. I am a champion of QLA. Useful diagnostic tool for students & teachers. Looking forward to your #thisisme speak soon :-)
Kevin Hewitson Kevin Hewitson @advocatingcreativity 2 years ago
May I recommend this article: "Assessment without levels. Is it Possible?" Link: http://wp.me/p2LphS-kO

I first used conditional formatting with Excel back in 2000. Wow I just realised how long ago that was! I found deciding on the thresholds for the three defined colours was the challenge, Yo uare stil lmarking but if you start as a teacher asking "What do I want to know my students know/understand" it makes writing the questions to cover topics much easier. I still had a fight with the students who wanted to know what mark they got but eventually they relised I was not going to tell them and then they focused on the three possible conditions:
a) I have demonstrated an thorough understanding of the topic.
b) I need to revise this area
c) I need to review the whole topic .

The analysis at a class level is most interesting and helps the teacher analyse their own teaching, the resources/approach they use and the areas they need to focus on. A much more efficient way of targeting revision too.

David Rogers David Rogers @davidrogers 2 years ago
Great to see you on Staffrm Kristian. It's been far too long since we caught up. I have to admit to being a fan of question level analysis - it certainly has made an impact in our departments over the past two years. I find useful insights into students' learning and performance are given.
Kristian Still Kristian Still @kristianstill 2 years ago
There is certainly a tangible atmospheric change when the pupils anticipate their summary sheets. Cheers Dave.
Mark O'Shea Mark O'Shea @mjaos1 2 years ago
An excellent read and just playing with the tool now. Think this will make a real difference with my students. I will let you know how it goes and share my experience. Do i need a password to alter tabs??
Kristian Still Kristian Still @kristianstill 2 years ago
Yes. The tool IP is really Pete Atherton. Please ask @dataeducator - otherwise the tool is functional.
{{ modalTitle }} {{{ modalData }}} {{ modalTitle }} {{{ modalData }}} Join the conversation
Sign in or sign up to post comments, follow colleagues, recommend stories and build your own professional profile.
Staffrm is the professional network for educators passionate about their work.
Please Sign In {{ modalData }} Sign In